How Animal Hoarding Cases Spiral Into Tragedy—and What Cities Must Do Now

Ask Me Anything #16 / Animal Politics with Ed Boks

It started with a smell.

Neighbors in Brooklyn complained for years—about the stench, the howling, the visible neglect. They called 311. They pleaded for wellness checks. But no one came.

When authorities finally entered the home, they found 115 dogs crammed into a toxic, airless space. Five were already dead. The woman who kept them—a retired school psychologist living alone, mentally unwell—was also deceased.

This was not just a tragedy. It was a catastrophic failure of our systems. And it is not an isolated case. These preventable horrors continue to unfold across New York and the nation, with animals suffering in silence while neighbors, first responders, and local officials watch—often helplessly—from the sidelines.

Would You Know What to Look For? Behind this door, 115 dogs suffered. The signs were there—but no one acted in time. (AI Image)

This Week’s AMA Question

Given the legal, mental health, and systemic failures revealed in the Brooklyn case, what reforms could New York and other cities adopt to stop these tragedies before they explode?

Animal Politics’ Response

Thank you for raising this vital question. The Brooklyn case—like many before it—underscores just how broken our response to animal hoarding remains. It is a human tragedy, a public health hazard, and a slow-motion disaster for animals—all allowed to unfold in plain sight.

The Law Is Clear—So Why Aren’t Agencies Acting?

Contrary to popular belief, law enforcement can intervene in animal hoarding cases under existing law. Courts, including in New York, have upheld that police may enter a residence without a warrant when animals are in visible or audible distress or face imminent harm.

In People v. Chung, officers lawfully entered a home after hearing a dog in clear distress. Exigent circumstances—like clear suffering or death—permit intervention.

Yet in practice, many agencies default to inaction, citing privacy laws or bureaucratic red tape. The result? Chronic, unchecked suffering and irreversible harm.

The Real Problem: A Disconnected, Reactive System

Animal hoarding is not just about animals. It's about people in crisis—often older, isolated, and mentally unwell—falling through the holes in the community’s “safety-net”.

In Brooklyn, a woman descended into psychological collapse while dozens of animals deteriorated around her. Despite years of complaints, no coordinated intervention occurred. There were no wellness checks. No mental health outreach. No early action.

Why? Because our systems are fragmented. Agencies don’t share information. Mental health isn’t prioritized. Animal control is siloed. And without institutional mandates to collaborate, everyone waits—until it's too late.

In Georgia on July 1, officials rescued over 260 animals—mostly dogs from a backyard breeder turned hoarder—only after neighbors reported a foul odor. It was one of five hoarding crises in just two weeks. Local authorities cited the lack of breeder oversight and inadequate enforcement capacity, underscoring the urgent need for interagency coordination and stronger breeding laws.

A Model That Worked: The Maricopa County Approach

During my tenure as Executive Director of Maricopa County Animal Care & Control in Arizona, we developed a model that directly addresses these gaps. By partnering with the County’s Public Health Department, we embedded a psychologist position within the public health budget—tasked specifically with addressing hoarding and related mental health crises. Because I reported directly to the Public Health Director, our collaboration was seamless. This allowed us to intervene early, addressing both the human and animal sides of hoarding before situations escalated.

This model worked because it:

• Recognized hoarding as a public health and mental health issue, not just an animal problem.

• Provided dedicated mental health resources for intervention and support.

• Eliminated bureaucratic barriers through direct interagency collaboration.

• Empowered early, humane intervention—before tragedy struck.

This program worked. It saved lives—both animal and human. But it was dismantled after my departure, proving that reform cannot depend on individual leaders. It must be institutionalized.

Dogs and cats are the most common victims of animal hoarding—but they aren’t the only ones. Rabbits, birds, reptiles, even farm animals have suffered in silence behind closed doors. Hoarding is not species-specific—it’s systemic, and preventable. (AI Image)

What Needs to Change in NYC and Beyond

1. Train Law Enforcement

Law enforcement and animal control officers must be trained on their legal authority to intervene in cases of animal suffering, and protocols must be established to ensure timely action.

2. Build and Sustain Cross-Agency Accountability

Animal control, public health, mental health, and law enforcement must work together as equal partners. Cities should establish formal, lasting collaborations—codified in policy and reinforced through regular joint training, shared data systems, and cross-agency protocols. This ensures progress continues beyond any one administration and becomes part of how the system works.

3. Fund Mental Health Response

Cities must embed clinicians within public health or animal services—specialists equipped to respond with compassion and authority.

4. Honor Community Reports

Encourage neighbors and community members to report concerns, and ensure their complaints are taken seriously and acted upon.

5. Clarify and Reform Policy

Laws must be clarified to eliminate hesitancy. Agencies must be empowered—and obligated—to intervene when harm is evident.

6. Enforce Breeder Oversight

Require breeder licensing and regular inspections. Empower local agencies to intervene early when breeding operations show signs of hoarding, neglect, or loss of control.

From Tragedy to Prevention

The heartbreaking case in Brooklyn didn’t happen overnight. It happened over years—with warnings ignored, laws misunderstood, and lives lost. We don’t need more post-mortems. We need to act before the next case erupts.

Cities like New York already have the tools. What they lack is urgency, coordination, and the political will to lead with prevention instead of cleanup.

If you are a policymaker, advocate, or concerned citizen, demand these reforms. If you are in a position of authority, ensure your agency is trained and empowered to act. And if you are a neighbor or community member, keep speaking up—your voice can make the difference between years of suffering and a humane, timely intervention.

Together, we can build a system that protects both animals and people, and puts compassion and prevention at the heart of our response.

Addition Reading:

Three Deadly Sins – Cruelty, Neglect, and Hoarding

Have a question for Animal Politics with Ed Boks?

Submit your concerns or questions to ed@edboks.com and help shape the conversation. Together, we can build a system that protects both animals and people—and stops waiting until it’s too late.

Ed Boks is a former Executive Director of the New York City, City of Los Angeles, and Maricopa County Animal Care & Control Departments, and a former Board Director of the National Animal Control Association. His work has been published in the LA Times, New York Times, Newsweek, Real Clear Policy, Sentient Media, and now on Animal Politics with Ed Boks.

Stay Informed

For more analysis and updates on the evolving landscape of animal welfare policy, visit Animal Politics with Ed Boks.